Jason's Blog

Apple’s “big” little announcements

by on Jan.09, 2007, under General

Ok, so had to repost a comments on apple 's new product announcements.  Let's just say I'm underwhelmed.

On the iPhone – that's an impressive devise, but the price (particularly since it requires the 2 year contract), with data plan also required, makes it unfeasable.  Particularly without an expansion port such as an SD slot.  However, if development for it is doable, then it becomes FAR more interesting.  If you could program your own content, games, etc. then this is the Nokia 800 on crack.  Either way though, there's not enough information to tell whether this has enough features, clean enough interface, ease of development, to outweigh the tremendous costs.

The iTV thing is useless.   TOTALLY useless.  There's a few cases where it becomes a consideration – if it does a pull vs. a push system.  If the only media it displays has to be pushed to it, save the time & money and buy a Mac MINI or some other device that can handle external storage.  I don't intend to buy a device and then have to get up, walk to my bedroom to turn on my computer to stream stuff to my living room.  If it had more harddrive space or could use an external harddrive, then perhaps syncing my library would be worthwhile.  However, I've already got over 40gb of music, pictures, and video, which makes the thing pretty useless for the price for what I do.

The only other way the iTV could become useful is as an integrated media library – and that gets into the extra storage mentioned above.  This would require supporting external harddrives.  Even then though, it's limited in functionality, without having DVR abilities or a lot more functionality than listed.  If the thing supported external harddrives, then syncing the media from my desktop, ripping my dvd library to it, etc. etc., then that would be worthwhile, because I dont' have to dig through piles of CD's or go to half a dozen places to find my information – it's all in one place, easily browsable.

SO, the iTV is kinda worthless without some serious modifications and external harddrive support.  Maybe only half worthless if it does pulls instead of pushes.  The iPhone could rock, could suck, depending on interface, pricing, and how well development works for it (I still say it needs an expansion slot!).

Here's the thing to keep in mind too – I love apple products, having replaced my old windows desktop with an iMac and a Powerbook, but these products were just a total disappointment from what they could have produced.  PARTICULARLY for the price/feature comparison and particularly for the big hype that Apple produced over these products.  The jury is still out on the iPhone, but the iTV is a waste in my opinion.

1 Comment for this entry

  • kropp

    I actually really like the iphone – it’s a very well put together single handheld solution that serves many needs. It will probably sell very well, and make apple lots of money. I’ll probably have to get one as soon as they are introduced. There is nothing on the market now or even proposed, that will do what the iphone does that smoothly.

    I completely agree with you on the iTV. It is a silly product – I can see where the motivation is, to get people to purchase content from itunes – and if people can easily watch that content on their TV’s it would be slightly more appealing. But it’s already completely outdated, in that it doesn’t support 1080p HDTV. Apple already offers 1080p content via it’s quicktime trailers, and many of the new tv’s (even the moderately priced ones) offer 1080p. I would have liked to see them take more of a cutting edge approach, and offer all the web based content direct to TV, but also include a universal drive that plays HDDVD and Blue Ray discs.

    LG introduced such a drive at CES this year – that means no format war, especially if the price is reasonable. That little 40GB drive in the iTV will fill up pretty fast when people start downloading HD content at even 1080i – and since they’re touting that as a capability I’m sure they will offer that sort of content through itunes. They’re also competing with cable companies and DSS systems which already offer DVR’s that have 250GB drives – I just can’t see people making a wholesale change in the way they get their content to their TV’s. If they had made the iTV a true single box solution to everything, that would have made sense. It could have cable card technology and a much bigger HD, so it could be used as a cable box and DVR – I’m sure no cable system would want that though, as they sell and rent their own DVR’s.

    I agree completely, the iTV sucks.

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!


A few highly recommended websites...